Judgement 10881/21

Applicant nameSOLDATOV AND OTHERS
Applicant type Natural person (prisoner)
Number of applicants 38
Country Russia
Application no.10881/21, 35403/21, 3399/22, 4077/22
4477/22, 4755/22, 4935/22, 5234/22
5737/22, 5808/22, 5880/22, 10838/22
11410/22, 11775/22, 12538/22, 13837/22
14047/22, 18252/22, 19962/22, 20220/22
21519/22, 21802/22, 21968/22, 24229/22
24928/22, 25216/22, 25271/22, 25386/22
25461/22, 26001/22, 27548/22, 28788/22
32085/22, 33684/22, 34237/22, 41329/22
42453/22, 44999/22
Date 23/11/2023
Judges Branko Lubarda, President,
 Armen Harutyunyan,
 Ana Maria Guerra Martins
Institution Court
Type Judgment
Outcome Art. 8 Violation
Reason No legal basis
Type of privacy Informational privacy
Keywords Permanent surveillance
Facts of the case Permanent surveillance
Analysis Mini judgement in which the Court confirms its established jurisprudence, for permanent video surveillance of detainees in pre-trial or post-conviction detention facilities – , opposite-sex operators, detention in different cells with video surveillance, video surveillance in a lavatory and/or shower room.
Other Article violation? Yes, inter alia Article 3 ECHR
Damage awarded One applicant invoked Artilce 8 ECHR, 7,500 awarded in that case
Documents Judgment